NRA, SAF Tell Fifth Circuit Felon Gun Bans Need Dangerousness Proof
The NRA and Second Amendment Foundation have asked the full Fifth Circuit to judge lifetime gun bans on whether a person is actually dangerous, not just whether they carry a felony record.
Snapshot
The two groups filed an amicus brief in United States v. Cordova, a case now before the Fifth Circuit sitting en banc after the court vacated a May panel ruling. The brief backs neither side but urges judges to adopt a dangerousness-based historical test for evaluating as-applied challenges to the federal felon-in-possession law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).
Key points
- The case: Peter Villa Cordova pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm after prior convictions for drug possession and evading arrest with a vehicle, then challenged the federal ban as applied to him.
- The ask: NRA and SAF want the court to require proof a person poses a danger before permanently stripping gun rights, rather than relying on felony status alone.
- The history argument: The brief contends founding-era laws disarmed people seen as violent threats, not nonviolent offenders who finished their sentences.
- The capital-punishment rebuttal: The organizations dispute using old felony death-penalty eligibility to justify modern lifetime bans, arguing not all felonies were capital crimes historically.
- What's next: Rehearing is scheduled for the Fifth Circuit's January 2027 session, alongside a related Commerce Clause case, United States v. Squire.
Quick take
This is a meaningful marker in the post-Bruen fight over who keeps the right to own guns after a felony conviction. Concealed Nation's reporting makes clear the brief proposes a framework, not a ruling, and § 922(g)(1) stays fully enforceable while the case is pending. Shooters watching Second Amendment litigation should treat this as one more data point in a slow-moving circuit split, not a green light for anyone currently barred from possessing firearms.
Read the full story: concealednation.org