News

NRA, SAF Tell Fifth Circuit Felon Gun Bans Need Dangerousness Proof

November 19, 2026

The NRA and Second Amendment Foundation have asked the full Fifth Circuit to judge lifetime gun bans on whether a person is actually dangerous, not just whether they carry a felony record.

Snapshot

The two groups filed an amicus brief in United States v. Cordova, a case now before the Fifth Circuit sitting en banc after the court vacated a May panel ruling. The brief backs neither side but urges judges to adopt a dangerousness-based historical test for evaluating as-applied challenges to the federal felon-in-possession law, 18 U.S.C. § 922(g)(1).

Key points

  • The case: Peter Villa Cordova pleaded guilty to possessing a firearm after prior convictions for drug possession and evading arrest with a vehicle, then challenged the federal ban as applied to him.
  • The ask: NRA and SAF want the court to require proof a person poses a danger before permanently stripping gun rights, rather than relying on felony status alone.
  • The history argument: The brief contends founding-era laws disarmed people seen as violent threats, not nonviolent offenders who finished their sentences.
  • The capital-punishment rebuttal: The organizations dispute using old felony death-penalty eligibility to justify modern lifetime bans, arguing not all felonies were capital crimes historically.
  • What's next: Rehearing is scheduled for the Fifth Circuit's January 2027 session, alongside a related Commerce Clause case, United States v. Squire.

Quick take

This is a meaningful marker in the post-Bruen fight over who keeps the right to own guns after a felony conviction. Concealed Nation's reporting makes clear the brief proposes a framework, not a ruling, and § 922(g)(1) stays fully enforceable while the case is pending. Shooters watching Second Amendment litigation should treat this as one more data point in a slow-moving circuit split, not a green light for anyone currently barred from possessing firearms.

Read the full story: concealednation.org