Thomas Signals Doubts on Broad Gun-Free Zones as Court Skips Maryland Case
The Supreme Court won't touch Maryland's gun-free zones, but Justice Clarence Thomas just put every state's sensitive-place list on notice.
Snapshot
On November 16, 2026, the Court denied certiorari in Novotny v. Moore, letting a Fourth Circuit ruling stand that upheld Maryland's carry restrictions in places like mass transit, state parks, and venues serving alcohol. AmmoLand reports that Thomas, writing separately, questioned whether such broad bans square with the historical test he authored in Bruen, even while agreeing the case itself wasn't the right vehicle to resolve it.
Key points
- Cert denied: The Supreme Court declined to review Maryland's restrictions, leaving the Fourth Circuit's Kipke v. Moore decision, which upheld nearly all the challenged location bans, in place.
- Thomas dissents on the merits, not the outcome: According to AmmoLand, Thomas agreed with denying cert for procedural reasons, since the case bundled too many different location types for one clean ruling, but he made clear he doubts Maryland's bans survive Bruen's historical-tradition test.
- Narrow tradition vs. broad bans: Thomas pointed out that history supports only limited gun-free zones, think legislatures, polling places, courthouses, not blanket prohibitions covering parks, transit, restaurants, and public gatherings.
- Not just Maryland: AmmoLand notes Thomas cited New Jersey (25+ restricted categories), New York (20), and California (29) as states running the same playbook of stacking sensitive-place designations.
- Invitation for round two: Thomas explicitly called for a future, narrower case to force the Court's hand on specific sensitive-place laws.
Quick take
Nothing changes for Maryland carriers today, the restrictions stand, and that's the practical headline. But Thomas's statement reads like a roadmap for litigators: stop bundling every gun-free zone into one mega-case and bring the Court a single, sharply defined provision. If states keep expanding "sensitive places" into ordinary life, AmmoLand's coverage suggests this issue isn't closed so much as queued up for round two.
Read the full story: ammoland.com