Attorney Says Connecticut Misreads History in AR-15 Ban Defense
Connecticut's defense of its AR-15 ban at the Supreme Court is leaning heavily on centuries-old English laws, and Second Amendment attorney Alan Beck says the state's reading of that history doesn't hold up.
Snapshot
Beck, who litigated Wolford v. Lopez, broke down Connecticut's reply brief in the combined Viramontes and Grant cases for The Reload. He argues the state cites medieval and early American laws as outright weapons bans when the actual historical record shows something narrower, and in some cases, no ban at all.
Key points
- Old law, weak fit: Beck notes Connecticut reaches back to 14th-century English statutes, which he says the Supreme Court is unlikely to credit given its Bruen-era skepticism of regulations far removed from the Founding.
- Lancegay mischaracterization: Connecticut treats a 1383 law as a lancegay possession ban, but Beck says it only restricted carrying the weapon while mounted without royal license, not owning one.
- Historians over lawyers: Beck told Reload founder Stephen Gutowski he set aside legal commentary and consulted medieval historians directly, concluding lancegays were likely "freely legal to own."
- Wills as evidence: Beck points to court-recorded wills bequeathing lancegays as proof the weapon wasn't actually banned, since courts wouldn't have processed an illegal transfer.
- Pattern of selective citation: Beck says similar issues turn up across other historical examples Connecticut cites, including crossbow and handgun restrictions, which he argues get stripped of context.
Quick take
This is a straightforward test of whether Bruen's historical-analogue framework can survive being stretched over laws attorneys clearly didn't research deeply enough. Beck's work, due to matter when the case is argued December 2, suggests Connecticut's brief won't hold up well under scrutiny from justices who already signaled skepticism of distant historical comparisons.
Read the full story: bearingarms.com