Guns

Benelli M2, M2-G1, M4 Tested Head-to-Head for Speed and Reliability

November 17, 2026

Benelli owns the inertia and gas-shotgun conversation three times over, and GunsAmerica's latest comparison digs into which of the M2, M2-G1, and M4 actually earns its keep at the range.

Snapshot

GunsAmerica put the classic M2, the newer gas-operated M2-G1, and the military-proven M4 through several hundred rounds apiece. According to the outlet, none of the three malfunctioned during testing, but the M2-G1 posted the fastest split times of the group, challenging the M4's status as the default combat shotgun pick.

Key points

  • M4's pedigree: GunsAmerica notes the M4 carries the strongest service history and military credentials of the three, the result of decades of combat use.
  • M2-G1's speed and price: The site reports the rear-piston M2-G1 delivered the quickest testing performance while costing substantially less than the M4 EXT.
  • Classic M2's simplicity: The inertia-driven M2 is described as the lightest of the three and the cleanest-running, since it skips the gas system entirely.
  • Reliability across the board: GunsAmerica says all three ran several hundred rounds without malfunctions, though none handled very light target loads under 1,000 fps reliably.
  • What should drive the decision: The article argues buyers should weigh track record, price, weight, maintenance demands, and ammo compatibility rather than assume one action type is universally better.

Quick take

The split here isn't about which shotgun is "best," it's about what you're optimizing for. If proven combat history matters most, GunsAmerica's data points toward the M4. If speed and price matter more, the M2-G1 makes a real case. The classic M2 still wins on simplicity and weight for buyers who don't need a gas gun's extra mass.

Read the full story: gunsamerica.com