Guns

Worn Underwood M1 Carbine Prints 2.5-Inch Groups at 100 Yards

November 15, 2026

The M1 Carbine's reputation as a lightweight plinker with so-so accuracy gets a reality check in a new GunsAmerica Digest piece, which puts a well-worn Underwood example through its paces and comes away impressed.

Snapshot

GunsAmerica Digest revisits the M1 Carbine decades after its WWII service, arguing the compact semi-auto is still a genuinely enjoyable shooter. The author's battered Underwood test gun put up 2.5 to 3-inch groups at 100 yards, numbers that push back against the carbine's long-standing reputation for mediocre precision.

Key points

  • Accuracy beats the legend: the author reports 2.5–3-inch, 100-yard groups from a rough Underwood M1 Carbine, calling into question the gun's old reputation as an inaccurate wartime tool.
  • Historical pedigree: the article leans on the carbine's WWII-era significance as part of its enduring appeal, not just as a shooter but as a piece of history.
  • Handling praised: the piece highlights the M1 Carbine's light weight and fast handling as major strengths that still hold up against modern expectations.
  • Well-worn gun, solid results: the tested example was described as battered, making its accuracy numbers more notable to the author rather than attributable to a pristine, collector-grade rifle.

Quick take

GunsAmerica Digest frames this as proof the M1 Carbine deserves more credit than its reputation suggests, and the group sizes from a beat-up Underwood back that up. For shooters who dismiss the platform as a historical curiosity rather than something worth putting rounds through, the piece argues otherwise.

Read the full story: gunsamerica.com